Socrates the socratic problem socrates lived in athens from 470469 until 399 bce. Ross with copious explanations of references implicit in the dialogue. Easily combine multiple files into one pdf document. A further decade of undiminished intellectual powers seems to be available to the platonic socrates. Garvin 20 introduction it would not be possible to overestimate the importance of socrates in the development of the western episteme. A proper interpretation of the accounts of the trial, platos apology and xenophons apology, are best thought of as responses to aftertrial criticisms that socrates failed at his defense. The work is important in that, aside from platos famous apology, it is the only written account dealing with the trial of socrates extant. Socrates exceptional service at delium is also mentioned in the laches, by the general the dialogue is named after 181b. The demonstration of such a proposition is too great a task in this context. Socrates, money, and the grammar of apology 30b 24. Each book was the authors literary perceptions and interpretations of the guiltyverdict against the public man socrates. The apology of socrates to the jury is xenophons literary contribution to the many apologia written to explain the trial of socrates 399 bc to the athenian public. The apology of socrates is a literary composition of plato capturing socrates thinking technique of inquiry. Apology of socrates and crito, with extracts from the phaedo and symposium and from xenophons memorabilia.
Apology of socrates by xenophon the internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Others have written on this theme, and all without exception have touched upon 3 the lofty style of the. The introduction to marchants translation says that. Plato was a friend of socrates that went to the oracle at delphi and asked a question concerning socrates wisdom. The memorable thoughts of socrates by xenophon, paperback. The apologiathat socrates takes makes the entirety of this book.
He recounted the events in anabasis, his most notable history. The fullest extant account of socrates at this crisis is to be found in platos euthyphro, apology, crito, and phaedo. If plato irritates you as much as he does me this is a must read. Like plato, xenophon is an authority on socrates, about whom he wrote several books of dialogues the memorabilia and an apology of socrates to the jury, which. In the apology socrates compares his military service to his courtroom. How you, men of athens, have been affected by my accusers, i do. Socrates wrote none of his own thoughts and activities down, leaving that to his associates. Fowler translation, loeb 19 edited with introduction and notes by e. Together with platos apology of socrates, and to a lesser extent xenophons memorabilia, it is the only substantial contemporary record we possess of the speech socrates made in his own defense at his trial. Xenophons socrates although socrates himself left behind no writings for us, his disciples aeschines, antisthenes, aristippus, cebes, crito, euclides, phaedo, simmias, xenophon, and plato wrote socratic.
Xenophon was away at the time, involved in the events of the march of the ten thousand. In other dialogues, the meaning comes from the interaction of socrates with his interlocutors. Plato and xenophon on the trial of socrates comparison. The meaning of the apology comes from the total scene, socrates statements in dramatic context. This was typed from dakyns series, the works of xenophon, a fourvolume set. Socrates was said to be the first philosopher in greece to discourse on the conduct of life and was the first to be executed. The account of socrates decision to accept death, which was given to xenophon by socrates companion hermogenes, is that socrates was an old man and it was socrates view that for him death was more to be desired than life according to the entry. False socrates at the end of the trial admitted that he had corrupted the youth and did not really believe in the gods of the state. Xenophon feels that socrates was made a scapegoat because of a past association with alcibiades. Xenophon is another great chronicler of the life and ideas of. Among the reminiscences of socrates, none, as it seems to me, is more deserving of record than the counsel he took with himself after being. As the main argument, he points out the absence of a plausible explanation in other so called apologies that could justify socrates preference of.
It is true that others have written about this, and that all of them have reproduced the loftiness. But for the memorabilias date, seyfferts dictionary has only after 393 b. However his teachings were interpreted, it seems clear that socrates main focus was on how to live a good and virtuous life. The influence of platos crito and phaedo on xenophons. Grube translated and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. This is evident in the apology, but even more perhaps in platos phaedo the account of the day of socrates death. Apology xenophon, dakyns translation wikisource, the. Among the reminiscences of socrates, none, as it seems to me, is more deserving of record than the counsel he took with himself 2 after being cited to appear before the court, not only with regard to his defence, but also as to the ending of his life. Memorabilia is also known by its latin title commentarii and a variety of english translations recollections, memoirs, conversations of socrates, etc. For my part, even i nearly forgot myself because of them, so persuasively did they speak.
Socrates held virtue to be the greatest good in life because it alone was capable of securing ones happiness. Continuing where apology left off, crito visits socrates in prison in hopes of busting socrates out. Most of those works are lost, except for those of plato and xenophon and some fragmentary texts of a few others. Xenophon of athens 430354 bc was an ancient greek associate of socrates, the great philosopher. An exhaustive pointbypoint commentary on the apology by kelley l. It is unfunny how easily his stance can be misconstrued as religious symbolism. The trial and death of socrates translated by g m a grube. The literary work is the best presentation to western philosophy plato 125. The paper explains that both authors describe socrates defense and his reactions to the verdict and sentencing, but the main difference between the two works is the perspective, with platos apology written from the firstperson perspective, and xenophons apology of. Others have written on this theme, and all without exception have touched upon 3 the lofty style of the philosopher.
Certainly i would pride and preen myself if i had this knowledge, but i do not have it, gentlemen. Xenophon of athens, apology loeb classical library. That xenophons apology of socrates to the jury deserves our attention, despite its now fashionable neglect, is easy to demonstrate. The lecture begins with an explanation of why platos apology is the best introductory text to the study of political philosophy. Socrates in his apology can be explained by a similar polemical motive. In the year 399 bc, socrates, then about seventy years old, was brought to trial by anytus, meletus, and lycon on an indictment charging subversion of the citys gods and corrupting its young men. Apology of socrates it seems to me fitting to hand down to memory, furthermore, how socrates, on being indicted, deliberated on his defence and on his end. Platos socrates, on the other hand, is shown with undiminished powers. Xenophons defense of socrates ancient history encyclopedia.
The account of socrates decision to accept death, which was given to xenophon by socrates companion hermogenes, is that socrates was an old man and it was socrates view that for him death was more to be desired than life according to the entry xenophon in the oxford. Socrates takes a stand and stands strong on his principle. In contrast to the central claim, that socrates sought an easy escape from old age, plato represents him as telling the jury that he can face death calmly because of his confidence in an afterlife a doctrine elaborated in the. While it is true that socrates occupies a position in a continuum of philosophical. Apology of socrates and crito, with extracts from the. According to the highly speculative entry for xenophon in the ocd 2nd edition, the memorabilias books 12 were written c. The book illustrates how socrates significantly founded a new mission for philosophy. An excellent discussion and introduction to the historical background and the life and character of socrates at the classics technology center provided by ablemedia curriculum guides commentary on platos apology of socrates. Wittgensteins logic of language site map pages about socrates. He is of the opinion that a this short document of 19 pages is a negligible quantity on its own but it is a remarkable complement to platos four dialogues on the. Man, you dont speak well, if you believe that a man. Preparers note first published 1897 by macmillan and co. After the execution of socrates in 399 bc, a number of his followers wrote dialogues featuring him as the protagonist and, in. Platos apology of socrates how you, men of athens, have been affected by my accusers, i do 17a not know 1.
Even death is a trivial matter for the truly virtuous individual who realizes that the most important thing in life is the state of his soul and the actions which spring from it. Plato was not present at socrates trial, so he relied on socrates own written account for the apology, which socrates had produced in his prison cell awaiting execution. In the case of the apology, we have seven main characters implied in the action. It is amongst his earliest works and the oldest document of greek philosophy. The memorabilia was probably completed after 371 bc, as one passage iii. How to merge pdfs and combine pdf files adobe acrobat dc. Go here for more about socrates apology by xenophon. The author xenophon presents socratess megalegoria boastful manner of. It follows the english translation of xenophons the apology, the account of socrates defense speech at trial, delivered at athens, greece 399 bc. The apology is a socratic dialogue by xenophon, a student of socrates. The focus remains on the apology as a symbol for the violation of free expression, with socrates justifying his way of life as a philosopher and defending. Socrates never gave the speech which is titled the apologia.
This free online tool allows to combine multiple pdf or image files into a single pdf document. But after his death and perhaps before, many greeks wrote socratic works which featured him as a character. Far more obviously than plato xenophon calls attention in his writings to his own relationship with socrates. Xenophon musuem del prado it seems to me fitting to hand down to memory, furthermore, how socrates, on being indicted, deliberated on his defence and on his end. The memorabilia is a recollection of socrates in word and deed, to show his character as the best and happiest of men. Notable among these critics was, allegedly, phaedo, a fellow student of socrates, whose writings are now lost, and xenophon, whose memorablia presents a different view of socrates than that presented by plato.
By thomas day seymour, with a vocabulary classic reprint plato plato on. The apology and trial of socrates plato and xenophon by. Xenophon views socrates death in more concrete and less theoretical terms than plato. Our pdf merger allows you to quickly combine multiple pdf files into one single pdf document, in just a few clicks. Just as xenophon never mentions this belief either in the apology or in the memorabilia, so plato never mentions fear of old age as a motive. A comparison of the defense speeches of plato and xenophon. Socrates was about 45 years old at the time of his trial. It is true that others have written about this, and that all of them have reproduced the loftiness of his words,a fact which proves that his utterance really was of the character intimated. Crito, and i am fully conscious that there is little in this book that has not been said previously by other. While plato acknowledges that socrates failed in conventional terms, and develops an alternative framework for evaluating success and failure, xenophon makes the more outrageous claim that socrates was a success in conventional terms. Xenophons other famous work, memorabilia, deals in part with his memories of socrates, and in the passage below, he addresses socrates trial and execution by the athenians in 399 bce.
1129 858 1545 574 474 66 299 1181 1422 1447 336 163 577 1335 596 1463 984 72 104 250 986 1545 401 983 1611 399 828 472 393 237 315 471 707 1084 881 393 904 519 1053 411 527 1447 1280